Fast Eddys Pizza and Bar, located at 4248 Main St in Downers Grove, is quickly becoming a favorite for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. The engaging atmosphere and welcoming owners create an experience that feels like home. Customers are especially raving about their mouthwatering Chicago tavern-style pizza—with popular choices like the 18” Paulies pepperoni drizzle, featuring a delightful blend of ricotta and honey over crispy crust.
Beyond pizza, the menu shines with juicy, meaty wings and exceptional homemade meatballs, both receiving high praise for their flavor and generous portions. Reviewers commend the creamy, sweet cannoli as the perfect finish to any meal. Service is consistently described as excellent, reflecting the owners' commitment to providing a warm and inviting dining atmosphere. Whether you’re dining in or opting for carryout, being surrounded by the intoxicating aroma of freshly made dishes enhances the experience.
With affordable pricing and a diverse menu, Fast Eddys stands out as a must-visit for both families and pizza aficionados. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a heartfelt experience that keeps guests coming back for seconds.
Amenities and More
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Comfort food
Quick bite
Dining options
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Photos
Reviews For Fast Eddys Pizza and Bar
Nicholas P
Jul 2,2025
One month update: We decided to dine in to get the full experience. I didn’t get any pizza this time because I wanted to try other things on the menu. It was pretty empty on a Wednesday night after 7:30 pm. Just a FYi, it’s 1 wings on Wednesdays and the wings are very meaty. We ordered a dozen wings, Mama Tucci’s Italian homemade meatballs, bucatini spaghetti, and cannoli. Service was excellent. Prices were reasonable for the generous portions. -wings 5 - we got the garlic parmigiana and the wings had great flavor on the inside and outside. Meat was very juicy. -meatballs 5 - these are very big and cheesy. I like the seasoning that went inside. Not salty. -bucatini spaghetti 5 - you get a huge plate of salad before receiving the spaghetti. The spaghetti comes with 2 huge meatballs and the noodles are chewy and tasty. -cannoli 5 - I love the sweet cream filling. It’s finger licking good. ———————————————— It honestly makes me laugh when reading recent reviews because you can tell when someone uses Chat GPT to write reviews. It’s painstakingly bad and trying too hard. I came here for a carry out but I would love to dine in. They have a good amount of seating available and plenty of parking. To find them, they’re located on the right side of Panda Express in a separate parking lot. The owners were very welcoming. The aroma from the pizza was very intoxicating on the way home. I ordered the 18” Paulies pepperoni drizzle. Ingredients are pepperoni, drops of ricotta cheese, and honey. It’s Chicago tavern style. Once you take that first bite, you can immediately feel the soft crunch along with the sweetness coming from the honey. You can feel pretty stuffed after 10 pieces, so I recommend sharing this with your family, friends, or significant others. If you do decide to take it home, use a pizza stone to heat it up. It’ll retain that crunchiness. A cheap pizza pan won’t do it much justice.
Natalie Passarelli
Jun 16,2025
The pizza and wings were very delicious! We also met the owner and he was really kind. Wings were crispy with great flavor. The pizza was a perfect tavern style. Found our new pizza spot!
Mitch Vruggink
May 9,2025
FAST Eddy’s was truly amazing! The food, Eddy, the beers everything was perfect! I can’t wait to come back again! “Cash is King” call Eddy direct for the fastest service!
Lauren D'Ag
Apr 18,2025
It was the day after Christmas, back home from Pittsburgh, where we currently live, for a holiday visit. We were bummed because our first dinner choice was closed, but destiny took the wheel on our pizza quest and led us to where we were meant to be: Fast Eddys. It turned out both Eddys (yep, 2 Eddys!) were yinzers from Pittsburgh and THE NICEST guys!! We talked about PNC park and Primanti's and it reminded us what a small world it is. So the vibe and service is awesome n'at but the food?? Oh man...the meatballs-- super fresh and high quality meat served with plenty of gravy (red sauce). The pizza--excellent tavern style with perfect crispy crust (get the sausage). And the cannoli are special; reminded me of my youth growing up in Chicagoland. We will definitely be back for the chicken parm and the company!! We left feeling like family. Kismet led us to this place and we can't wait to return on our next trip back home. Thanks Eddys and Go Stillers!!
Dina Walters
Apr 8,2025
OUTSTANDING. The food, service, and ambience are enthralling. The pizza and wings were delicious and made to order. The salad was unique with fresh mozzarella, ricotta, and homemade meatballs. We ended the meal with the gelato. Ed, Chrissy, and the chef were all excellent and made it a memorable dining experience. 10 out of 10.
Dave Urbanski
Apr 2,2025
Soo i checked out this place today for the first time. We got the paulie was definitely a soild 7.6 pizza and the crunch was on point . If ya in the area definitely ck this place out i will no doubt be back
Yahaira Bonilla
Mar 26,2025
I was looking for an authentic Italian place and saw all the amazing reviews! And they were all absolutely true. The pasta was so fresh and the gravy was to die for. Pizza was fresh and hot and was even topped with a delicious hot honey sauce that I would definitely recommend trying when you order. Customer service is great too they check in frequently and make sure you’re happy with your food. 10/10
Sandra Locascio
Mar 22,2025
Absolutely fabulous food! The service was fast and informative. We had the 18" pizza which was enough for 4 adults and leftovers. The desserts were delicious, cannoli and ice cream bomb. We will be going back. Don't miss out on this great Italian food. You can order by phone and take out too.
Reviews For Fast Eddys Pizza and Bar